Does it really matter where you go to college?
February 14, 2017
Throughout high school, there is one heavy weight we must bear: higher education and all of the decisions that surround it. Where should I apply? Who will accept me? What will it cost? Can I afford it? The one goal that practically all of us share: finding the college that right for us.
Does it really matter where you go to college? In many cases yes, and in many cases, no. It’s important to understand these cases, so that you choose your college wisely, and how to spend your hard earned money. A study from the Wall Street Journal stated: “diplomas from prestigious schools boost future earnings only in certain fields, while in others, they simply don’t make a difference.”
For students interested in majoring in business or liberal arts, choosing a college is a very important decision. On the other hand, for students interested in pursuing a career in the STEM field, choosing a college is not as critical. For example, if a student were to go to the University of Pennsylvania for engineering, instead of Texas A&M, the average salary difference would be less than $1,000. But the tuition difference would be over $167,000.
There is a very big difference in salary income for business majors and social science majors. Graduates in the business field, who attended highly selective colleges, earned 12% more than graduates who went to a college with an average acceptance rate. Social science majors from prestigious schools earned 11% more than graduates who went to a college with an average acceptance rate. There are many possible reasons for these disparities. For business majors, more prestigious schools may offer better alumni networks and other connections with potential employers. For the the humanitarian and social science fields, more prestigious schools may offer better university resources for graduate programs. However, where you go to college does not ultimately determine how successful you’ll be in any major that you pursue, especially in business.
A New York Times columnist named Frank Bruni wrote a book called Where You Go Is not Who’ll You’ll Be, which sheds light on the situation. It provides lengthy examples of Americans, from all different backgrounds, who found success without going to a highly competitive college. For instance, he points out the fact that among the American-born CEO’s of the top 100 companies in Fortune 500, only 30 went to an Ivy League college or an equally selective college. The CEO of Disney went to Ithaca College, which has an acceptance rate of 67%.
Many other executives never even pursued an MBA. Many employers are also more focused on the experience of the candidate, rather than where they went to school. When the Wall Street Journal asked recruiters the best universities for their entry level hires, the top five were Penn State, University of Illinois, Purdue, Texas A&M, and Arizona State. All of them are public universities, hardly elite or highly selective. As long as you work hard, and have good connections/opportunities, you can achieve success in any career opportunity that you want to pursue.
jessica yerger • Mar 27, 2017 at 7:21 AM
“Man often becomes what he believes himself to be. If I keep on saying to myself that I cannot do a certain thing, it is possible that I may end by really becoming incapable of doing it. On the contrary, if I have the belief that I can do it, I shall surely acquire the capacity to do it even if I may not have it at the beginning.”
– Mahatma Gandhi
Lexie lewis • Mar 13, 2017 at 12:35 PM
In my opinion where you go to college does matter. If you go to a community college sure getting a diploma is going to be a great achievement but you would get better jobs if you went to an Ivy League school. Also going to a division one school would probably give you more dept which could affect how well you do after college.
Tony Garza • Mar 13, 2017 at 12:27 PM
While many people seem to believe that going to the wrong college means you’ll live a horrible life and your entire world is over, it’s important to remember that at any college you’ll be able to find friends/ activities and find somewhere to fit into. Going into a STEM field most certainly means, go to a cheaper college. I personally would rather pay $167k less to go to a slightly less prestige college.
colin Murphy • Mar 13, 2017 at 12:22 PM
College does matter, but you don’t have to go to your dream school if you cab get the same degree at a different college for less money.
Marta Kheeykeiy Kasica-Soltan • Mar 13, 2017 at 8:09 AM
The data, when used to support these types of articles, are usually used in part (at best). People choose to use the data that supports their position while neglecting some of the same data that fails to gain credence to their cause. What I would like to know is what percentage of students who graduated from Texas A&M, University of Pennsylvania… or even ESU, are employed after 6 months of time? How many of these students are happily employed doing jobs that their colleges prepared them to do?
Livia Marga • Mar 13, 2017 at 8:07 AM
Let me first say that this is a very well written article!! Good job! This article is very broad though, everyones majors and futures are unique. In terms of education you can get the samr degree everywhere. But the dorms, the distance from home, the scholarships, etc., factor in as well! For me I know I want to be instate and a physical therapist doctor. That narrows it down to possibly 8 univeristies- many of which are far! And upon visiting their programs some did not seem to be worth their price tag! My top college happens to by my priciest! However its close to home, has a great program, great dorms with bathrooms in them, great area etc. And originally I didnt even care for it! Though I agree with this article in terms of degrees I feel as if there are many unique factors that determine whether college is an option/desire and which college is best for that individual!
Liberty Georgia • Mar 13, 2017 at 7:51 AM
In my eyes college is very important. The goal should be to apply to as many as you can. At first the place shouldn’t matter because there’s so many opportunities out there but have a place in mind. Once you get accepted to the ones you applied then narrow down your choice. The cost and the location definitely matters in terms of how much money will be spent just on transportation. I do agree that depending on your major and the career you want will limit your options or in some cases college isn’t needed. College is right for you when you put time and effort into something you will enjoy learning but don’t forget to make friends and have fun. College isn’t for everyone but it is always a option. A higher education will help you later on in your life. It is completely okay to go to a community because you can always transfer to anywhere. I enjoyed this article and thought it was well written and well informed.
Nicholas Bergman • Mar 13, 2017 at 7:45 AM
I think college is a great choice post high school, but not for everyone. Some people would rather go into the military or choose a career that does not require college. To each their own.
Daniel Ocasio • Mar 6, 2017 at 8:19 AM
If college Is important, Why do some people drop out?
Persin: I made a mistake
Me: then why did you go in the first place?
person: (no comment)
Me:((^_-) _/¯ really?…
Dylan hagerty • Mar 6, 2017 at 7:29 AM
Well thinking from a logical stand point you can get the same level of education from most schools but if you’re going to an ivy legue school you are getting a high level of education plus the name recognition which for most places you’re attempting to get a job or career would put you on the top of the list so yeah it does matter where you go to college
MIcah Hargrove • Mar 3, 2017 at 12:40 PM
This was a greatly written article. It made me believe that it doesn’t matter where you go anymore. You can go to a community college then go to a University later on and be able to still succeed rather than attending all 4 years at a university. You can be able to transfer from one school to another and still be able to succeed as well also. This great article has shown me that.
Samantha Castillo • Mar 3, 2017 at 12:36 PM
I loved how this article war written. It provided insight on statistics based on different situations but also speaks to the reader on a personal level. What college you go to wont define your success compared to someone that attended an Ivy League school and this is so true.
Samad Khan • Mar 3, 2017 at 12:33 PM
I believe that where you set off for college helps you shape who will get to be. In any case, I don’t think it is important all that much insofar as it’s a decent learning condition and a decent domain as a rule since a few people don’t have the cash to go to some costly, awesome school. For whatever length of time that the school works or worked for you, it ought to be clear when you go to get a vocation. Professions picking workers in view of where they headed off to college doesn’t generally sound good to me since you could go to a truly awesome, ivy class school and not do anything while you’re there or you could go to a fundamental school and make a truly incredible ordeal. I simply believe that schools matter in the feeling of framing your identity going to turn into.
Dyony Bueno • Mar 3, 2017 at 8:11 AM
Very good article. In order to be successful doesn’t mean you have to go to college for it. There’s a lot of people who went big and either didn’t finish high school or go to college.
Sadie Unangst • Mar 3, 2017 at 7:50 AM
I think that where you go to college helps you form who you’re going to become. But I don’t think it matters all that much as long as it’s a good learning environment and a good environment in general because some people don’t have the money to go to some expensive, great college. As long as the college works or worked for you, it should be obvious when you go to get a career. Careers choosing employees based on where they went to college doesn’t really make sense to me because you could go to a really great, ivy league college and not do anything while you’re there or you could go to a basic college and make a really great experience. I just think that colleges matter in the sense of forming who you are going to become.
Janiaya cummings • Mar 3, 2017 at 7:46 AM
Yes it matters where we go to college. You can’t just randomly pick a college and go to it. You have to do research on it and see if it’s a good school to attend.
College is where some kids will be spending there next 4 years living. So picking a random college would be bad. You have to pick one where you fit in. You also have to see if it’s a good environment to be in. So do research and pick the one that fits best for you.
Jackie Bauer • Mar 3, 2017 at 7:45 AM
I personally think this was such a well written article. It got me to think that in the end no matter if you go to an Ivy League university or a state or smaller college or university that everyone can accomplish something great and that it all depends on your connections and how hard you work and put forth effort.
Daniel Varghese • Mar 3, 2017 at 7:42 AM
I think it does matter, going to college, but it is how you go there. It is easy to just go straight for the same school for all 4 years. But would it not be easier to take it a step at a time, like saying going to community college for a couple years and then a main college for an even higher education.
Nia Skeet • Mar 1, 2017 at 7:21 AM
To be honest, college is a hit or miss situation..
Gianna roselle • Mar 1, 2017 at 7:21 AM
This was so nicely written out. Bravo!
Keyanna Safforld • Mar 1, 2017 at 7:20 AM
Very great story Alefiyah!
Jean M. Dunback-Costanzi • Mar 1, 2017 at 7:20 AM
If you would like to read more about this subject, I would recommend “Where You Go Is not Who You’ll Be” by Frank Bruni.